Newest: Women's hockey (2018), Men’s Rugby (2019), Women’s Rowing (2019)
Competition: Nazareth competes in the Empire 8 Conference with Alfred, Elmira, Hartwick, Houghton, Sage, St. John Fisher, Stevens Institute of Technology, and Utica. Men's volleyball competes in the United Volleyball Conference. The hockey teams are in the United Collegiate Hockey Conference.
2017-18 Empire 8 Conference champions: women's tennis, women's swimming and diving, and men's basketball. Golden Flyers also competed in the championships for men's soccer, women's soccer, women's volleyball, men's swimming and diving, men's volleyball, women's lacrosse and women's softball.
Individual All-Americans: women's soccer, women's volleyball, men's volleyball, men's lacrosse, men's basketball, men's hockey, women's swimming, men's track and field and women's track and field recently.
National champs: Men's lacrosse won the NCAA Division III national championship in 1992, 1996, and 1997 and reached the national title game in 1995, 1998, and 2004. Nazareth won the Molten Division III national title in men's volleyball in 2011.